A CRITIQUE OF EMILY CANNON’S PAPER: “ANIMALS MIGHT HAVE RATIONAL SOULS: INSIGHTS FROM CHIMPANZEE COLONY” (Published in International Journal of Philosophy and Public Affairs, Vol. 5 December, 2017)
A CRITIQUE OF EMILY CANNON’S PAPER: “ANIMALS MIGHT HAVE RATIONAL SOULS: INSIGHTS FROM CHIMPANZEE COLONY” Charles Kenechukwu Okoro Department of Philosophy, University of Nigeria, Nsukka. The Merits of the paper In the paper, “Animals might have Rational Souls: Insights from Chimpanzee Colony,” Emily Cannon advances a view that apparently supports the contemporary course for the promotion of animal rights. Drawing largely from Frans de Waal’s study of animal behaviour, using especially Chimpanzees, she advances this course with greater vigour by ascribing rational souls to animals. Systematically raising interesting philosophical questions, the paper is undoubtedly as thought-provoking as it is intellectually enriching. Its philosophical interest in the possibility of non-human animal consciousness makes for a re-assessment of man’s unique nature and privileged status in the universe, especially through comparison and contrast with those animals whose actions could approxi...